Brick Cheese: What It Is, Why It Melts Perfectly, and Why Detroit-Style Pizza Loves It

If you’ve ever enjoyed a crispy, cheesy slice of Detroit-style pizza, there’s a good chance you’ve already tasted one of the Midwest’s best-kept secrets: brick cheese. Known for its rich buttery flavor, incredible melt, and signature caramelized edges, brick cheese has become a favorite among cheese lovers and pizza enthusiasts alike.

At Something Cheesy, we love introducing customers to unique cheeses with deep roots in American cheese-making history. Whether you’re building the perfect charcuterie board, making gourmet sandwiches, or baking homemade Detroit-style pizza, brick cheese deserves a place in your kitchen.

What Is Brick Cheese?

Brick cheese is a semi-soft cheese that originated in Wisconsin during the late 1800s. The cheese gets its name from the traditional cheesemaking process, where actual bricks were used to press the curds and help shape the cheese wheel.

Brick cheese is known for:

• A mild, buttery flavor when young

• A slightly tangy and earthy taste as it ages

• A creamy texture with excellent melting qualities

• A rich orange-yellow color similar to cheddar

Many people describe brick cheese as sitting somewhere between cheddar and mozzarella. It has more flavor than mozzarella but still melts beautifully, making it ideal for hot dishes and comfort foods.

Where Did Brick Cheese Come From?

Brick cheese was first created in Wisconsin by American cheesemaker John Jossi, a Swiss immigrant who adapted European cheesemaking traditions to local dairy production. Wisconsin’s rich dairy culture helped brick cheese become a staple throughout the Midwest.

Today, Wisconsin remains the primary producer of authentic brick cheese and continues to be one of the top cheesemaking regions in the United States.

What Does Brick Cheese Taste Like?

Young brick cheese has a creamy, buttery taste with a smooth finish. As it ages, the flavor becomes stronger, tangier, and slightly pungent.

Because of its balanced flavor profile, brick cheese works well in both simple recipes and gourmet dishes.

Popular flavor notes include:

• Butter

• Toasted milk

• Mild cheddar

• Slight nuttiness

• Earthy tanginess in aged varieties

Why Brick Cheese Melts So Well

One reason brick cheese has gained popularity is its incredible melting ability. The higher fat content allows it to become smooth and creamy without separating or turning oily too quickly.

That makes it perfect for:

• Pizza

• Grilled cheese sandwiches

• Burgers

• Macaroni and cheese

• Cheese dips

• Hot sandwiches

• Casseroles

The melt creates a rich texture while still developing crispy browned edges when baked at high temperatures.

Brick Cheese and Detroit-Style Pizza

Detroit-style pizza has exploded in popularity across the United States, and brick cheese is one of the main reasons why.

Detroit-style pizza originated in Detroit during the 1940s. Unlike traditional round pizzas, Detroit-style pizza is baked in rectangular steel pans, creating a thick, airy crust with crispy caramelized cheese edges.

Authentic Detroit-style pizza traditionally uses Wisconsin brick cheese because it melts evenly and crisps perfectly along the sides of the pan.

Why Brick Cheese Works So Well on Detroit Pizza

Brick cheese helps create the signature characteristics Detroit pizza fans love:

• Crispy cheese crust around the edges

• Gooey melted center

• Rich buttery flavor

• Even browning during baking

• Perfect balance between crunch and softness

When baked in a Detroit-style pan, the cheese spreads all the way to the edges, where it caramelizes into a crispy golden crust that many pizza lovers consider the best part.

How to Use Brick Cheese at Home

Brick cheese is surprisingly versatile and easy to use in everyday cooking.

Best Uses for Brick Cheese

• Homemade Detroit-style pizza

• Cheeseburgers

• Melted cheese sauces

• Breakfast sandwiches

• Baked pasta dishes

• Gourmet grilled cheese

• Cheese boards and charcuterie spreads

For pizza, many chefs combine brick cheese with mozzarella for extra stretch and flavor balance.

Is Brick Cheese Similar to Mozzarella?

While both cheeses melt well, brick cheese has a richer flavor and creamier texture than mozzarella. Mozzarella is milder and stretchier, while brick cheese provides more depth and a buttery finish.

If you want pizza with more flavor and crispy cheese edges, brick cheese is often the better option.

Where to Buy Brick Cheese

Because authentic brick cheese is less common outside the Midwest, many people struggle to find it in standard grocery stores. Specialty cheese shops often carry higher-quality versions that provide the true flavor and texture Detroit-style pizza requires.

At Something Cheesy, we’re passionate about helping customers discover unique and delicious cheeses from across the country. Whether you’re searching for authentic Wisconsin brick cheese, artisanal cheese selections, or ingredients for your next pizza night, we’re here to help. Order Brick Cheese Online from Something Cheesy: Brick Cheese

Final Thoughts on Brick Cheese

Brick cheese is one of America’s most underrated cheeses. Its creamy texture, buttery flavor, and unmatched melting ability make it ideal for everything from gourmet sandwiches to authentic Detroit-style pizza.

Whether you’re a pizza enthusiast, cheese lover, or simply looking to try something new, brick cheese offers a flavorful experience that stands out from ordinary cheeses.

If you’re ready to experience authentic brick cheese for yourself, visit Something Cheesy online and explore our growing collection of specialty cheeses perfect for entertaining, cooking, and everyday enjoyment.

Frequently Asked Questions About Brick Cheese

Is brick cheese the same as mozzarella?

No, Brick cheese is not the same as mozzarella. While both cheeses melt very well, brick cheese has a richer, creamier flavor with more buttery notes. Mozzarella is milder and stretchier, while brick cheese provides a deeper flavor and creates crispier caramelized edges when baked.

Many pizza makers combine brick cheese and mozzarella together to get the perfect balance of flavor and stretch.

Why does Detroit-style pizza use brick cheese?

Authentic Detroit-style pizza traditionally uses brick cheese because it melts evenly and crisps beautifully around the edges of the pan. The cheese’s higher fat content helps create the signature golden-brown crust Detroit-style pizza is famous for.

When baked in a rectangular Detroit-style pan, the brick cheese spreads all the way to the edges, forming crispy caramelized cheese corners that many pizza lovers consider the best part of the pizza.

Where can I buy brick cheese in Kentucky?

Because brick cheese is a specialty cheese originally made in Wisconsin, it can sometimes be difficult to find in standard grocery stores. Specialty cheese shops such as Something Cheesy in Shelbyville, KY sells brick cheese by the 1/2 pound and more. When ordered and shipped from our online store we offer by the pound increments.

Does brick cheese melt better than cheddar?

In many recipes, yes. Brick cheese generally melts smoother and creamier than cheddar because of its moisture and fat content. Cheddar can sometimes become oily or separate when overheated, while brick cheese tends to stay smooth and consistent.

That’s one reason brick cheese is popular for:

• Detroit-style pizza

• Gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches

• Cheeseburgers

• Cheese sauces

• Hot dips and casseroles

Its melting qualities make it a favorite for recipes where texture matters just as much as flavor.

© 2024. All rights reserved.

Address:

Phone:

Email: